Inside Sarah Jessica Parker and Matthew Broderick’s Unusual Love Story

Sarah Jessica Parker Shares Rare Insight Into Family Life With 3 Kids

Sarah Jessica Parker is always so busy with acting and fashion and her charity work, and Matthew Broderick is always busy doing a play or a movie…

Just like that, it can be easy to forget that these two award-winning actors have been going home to each other at the end of those long days for almost 27 years.

“We cook every night,” Parker, who’s turning 59 on March 25, said on a July 2023 episode of Table for Two with Bruce Bozzi. “We really do cook five to six nights a week, for sure,” she added, explaining that they aren’t much for takeout. “We have always have a Sunday dinner—we invite people.”

But just in case they’re not cooking or hosting on any given night, they’re probably off doing something together, such as when they costarred in the Broadway revival of Neil Simon’s Plaza Suite in 2022, which moved to London’s West End earlier this year.

“I think she’s tremendously good,” Broderick complimented his wife’s acting acumen, speaking to The Telegraph. Playing a long-married couple having some major issues, “Boy, you would think it would [make us think about what makes a marriage work], but I don’t know that it has…It’s more about depending on each other onstage that’s educational.”

The 62-year-old added, “How to work together well is probably a good exercise for a couple.”

But the theater has always been one of their happy places.

The actors met in November 1991 when Broderick—who won a Tony at 21 for Brighton Beach Memoirs—directed a play for the Naked Angels Theater Company, which was founded by Parker’s big brothers Pippin and Toby (she’s one of eight siblings). 

He was best known to the masses then as the sweet-faced but wily class-cutter in Ferris Bueller’s Day Off but was already a veteran star of the stage. Parker, who once dated John F. Kennedy Jr., had recently broken up with Robert Downey Jr. after a storied tumultuous relationship (RDJ takes full credit for the rocky bits) and Broderick’s past girlfriends included Helen Hunt and Jennifer Grey.

Hoda Davaine/Dave Benett/Getty Images

“The first time I met her I was very struck by her,” Broderick recalled to The Telegraph. “She was very special, somebody you wanted to look at…I think she was wearing a bright orange puffy coat. And white long johns in a sort of waffle material and Timberland boots. She was very stylish.”

He remembered her outfit, too?!

Some months went by, though, before he finally drummed up the nerve to call her for a date on Feb. 1, 1992. “Then he left a very charming, very self-effacing message on the machine,” Parker told The New York Times. “You know, ‘Hi, it’s Matthew Broderick.’ You had to use your last name.”

For their first date, “We went to a movie together,” Broderick, who grew up in Greenwich Village, told the YES Network in 2012. “And I still remember very clearly seeing her walk down the street toward the movie theater…it’s very unique, because I wouldn’t remember most people the first time I saw them come down the street. [But] I remember it as clear as day.”

It didn’t even matter that he grew up rooting for the Mets and she was a Yankees fan.

Kevin Mazur/WireImage

As Parker gushed to the Los Angeles Times in March 1996, “He’s probably the funniest fellow I’ve met in my whole life. He’s so bright, so handsome, I think he’s the most handsome man I’ve seen in my life. And he inspires me. I’m mad for him, totally.”

She was about to star opposite Broderick in How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying on Broadway, her first time singing onstage in 16 years.

“I’m so nervous acting opposite him,” she admitted. “I don’t know how we’re going to manage this without laughing hysterically at each other. We do not discuss it. I don’t even want to rehearse—I’m going to go onstage with a big blinder on my head—I don’t know what I’m thinking.”

Ron Galella/WireImage

It was a running joke of his, she said. “We work together, we eat together, we sleep together, we wake up together, we work together, we eat together, we sleep together…” Parker said during their Broadway run. “It occurred to me that that was a dangerous part of this, that our world would become very small. There was always something nice about sharing your experiences. Now, all of a sudden our experiences are the same, and I don’t feel like I’m bringing a lot to the table.”

Just over a year later, they married on May 19, 1997, at Angel Orensanz Synagogue on the Lower East Side, with Broderick’s minister sister Jane officiating in front of 100 surprised guests, none of whom knew they were gathered for a wedding. 

And the bride wore black. 

“Oh, I wish it was because I was badass,” Parker said on Watch What Happens Live in 2016. “I just was too embarrassed to spend any time looking for a wedding dress. There was a store that I liked that I knew, and I just went and got whatever they had hanging.”

Getty Images

The dress wasn’t label-less—it was by Morgane Le Fay—but Parker has had a few twinges of regret about the lack of thought she put into it. Or the fact that at the time she actually went with black in hopes of not drawing too much attention to herself…on her wedding day. (She didn’t entirely buck tradition, though: She had an old coin, a new dress, a borrowed handkerchief and her teal-blue velvet Robert Clergerie shoes.)

“If I were getting married today, I’d likely wear cream, just to have that bridal experience,” Parker told Martha Stewart Weddings in 2015. “Now I would want my dress to have an Oscar de la Renta feel, pockets below the waist, a very fitted bodice, a huge skirt, in taffeta or duchesse satin. That silhouette appeals to me because it’s old-fashioned yet can look very modern.”

Admittedly, when it came time to tie the knot, Parker “never thought about a wedding dress,” she told People. “Had not one daydream about it. At one point I just simply remember thinking, ‘God, I really hope he asks me to marry him.’ I don’t know when or why. It was fairly early on.”

Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic

Meanwhile, when they got married, Parker’s professional life was on the verge of changing forever.

Through most the ’90s, the charming actress was movie-famous, known simultaneously for smart (Honeymoon in Vegas, Ed Wood) and silly (L.A. Story, Hocus Pocus, First Wives Club), albeit scene-stealing, supporting roles. She had her doubts about doing a TV series, and she has credited her longtime agent Kevin Huvane and her husband for encouraging her to accept the role of Carrie Bradshaw on Sex and the City.

At the 2004 Emmys, the couple, holding hands while the nominees were being read, shared a long, celebratory kiss when Parker won after the series’ final season. Her acceptance speech began with an apparent inside joke—”Matthew, James Wilkie, sweet”—and Broderick looked tickled.

By then they had become parents to son James Wilkie, now 21, Carrie having gone through a high- or no-waist dress phase on SATC in 2002 to cloak Parker’s growing bump.

“I’d rather be just having tea with an actress because it’s very nerve-wracking to be half-naked, pretending to have sex,” Broderick later told Parade. “I don’t get those kind of moments very often in movies. My wife does a lot more than I do. But Sarah Jessica and I are both pretty grown-up about watching each other’s love scenes on the screen.” 

Jamie McCarthy/WireImage

Broderick has also expressly called Parker a “very positive person” and “very unbitchy,” while he has to work harder on containing his flair for the negative. He told Parade, “When I’ve been unhappy, usually something good happens and it cheers me up. But I’ve also gotten help through books that I’ve read, and I’ve gone to psychiatrists. I’ve done everything I can think of to improve my attitude, so there isn’t only one thing that always cheers me up.” 

When they reached their 10th anniversary in 2007, Parker couldn’t believe it—in a good way.

“I mean, I knew that we had exceeded everybody’s expectations—kidding,” she said, laughing, on The Oprah Winfrey Show a few days before the milestone. “But he was the one that reminded me last week.” As for their plans, “we have no ideas and we have no babysitter. But I expect that we’ll probably cook dinner and spend a better part of the evening with James Wilkie.”

Jason Merritt/Getty Images

They had also promised each other that they wouldn’t buy presents because there was nothing either needed. “I would love a note,” Parker said. “So few of us actually write anything down now. There’s so little documentation of our feelings because everything’s emails.”

Then it’s a good thing she’s said such lovely things about her husband in interviews! Though, as she has acknowledged, she purposely has never said too much. Nor does she share too many intimate family moments on Instagram, figuring it’s important to keep most things private.

Funny enough, she told Harper’s Bazaar in 2013, “People have asked me about my marriage, ‘How do you make it work, and I say, ‘We don’t talk about it.’ That’s not really true. It’s sort of a nasty response.”

Seven years after James Wilkie was born, the family grew again on June 22, 2009, when they welcomed twin daughters Marion Loretta and Tabitha via surrogate. 

Bruce Glikas/FilmMagic

“We tried and tried and tried and tried to get pregnant [again],” Parker later told Vogue, “but it just was not to be, the conventional way—I would give birth as often as I could, if I could. I cherished all the milestones, the good and the bad.”

The process was yet another bonding experience for her and Broderick. “We couldn’t talk about the fact that we were having children to anybody for sooo long!” she said. “All the stuff that matters is secretive and worrisome. You can’t talk about how you feel about the woman who’s carrying your children; you can only talk about it to your husband. And he just doesn’t want to talk about it as much as you do.”

Fame continued to be a mixed bag, in that their work both financed their fantastic life and also meant people followed harassed their surrogate while she was pregnant, looking for dirt. “The most unsavory things have been done,” Parker lamented to Access Hollywood before the babies were born. “She’s had her phone hacked, her personal computer information hacked, she’s had threats against her and true harassment… She’s had friends threatened and family threatened and she’s had family of friends threatened.”

But when the babies were born, “I don’t remember anything but the blanket on the bed that they were lying on and my husband’s face and their faces and my son’s,” she told Vogue. “It’s literally as if sound is sucked from the room. Time stands still. It’s so different, and equally extraordinary.”

Moreover, she told Stella magazine, “We were just hopeful that we would have one healthy child. It was a wonderful shock getting two; the cherry on the sundae… [but] going from one to three children is a much bigger adjustment than becoming a mother in the first place. One child in retrospect seems a cake walk compared to where I stand today.”

Bruce Glikas/WireImage

And yet she seemed to have it handled.

“We painted our patio furniture ourselves…. I make my children’s food myself,” she told Vogue in 2010. “We put together their high chairs ourselves; we do a lot ourselves! We do our own grocery shopping, we go to the market ourselves, you know? I do my laundry.”

She shared with Vogue in 2011 that they didn’t have any live-in help, but employed a nanny for the twins and another babysitter-assistant-type staffer who saw to then 8-year-old James Wilkie’s schedule. “We’re pretty hands-on parents,” Parker said. “That’s something that’s important to both of us, and we don’t shirk it, because what’s the point in having a family if you’re not going to really participate in it, you know?”

Answering Vogue’s 73 Questions in 2014 at their West Village townhouse, Parker noted they’d been in the neighborhood for 13 years. (The following year they flipped a Greenwich Village property, for $18.25 million. In 2012 they added a residence in Brooklyn Heights to their portfolio, and in 2016 they reportedly snatched up two adjoining townhouses on their current street with an eye on creating one huge mega-mansion.)

Because Parker went on to be star on a show called Divorce, interviews while she was on the promotional circuit inevitably gravitate toward musings on family and marriage—namely what makes it work and what doesn’t. Having been married for more than two decades make Parker and Broderick the object of much romantic fascination anyway, but the personal questions actually aligned, at least partially, with the craft. (She was married the entire time she played the single lady, Carrie Bradshaw, after all.)

“There is an enormous amount of discussion and dissection and introspection [between Matthew and I] about it. We have common interests and we still really enjoy each other’s company,” Parker told London’s Telegraph in 2016. “We are suited to each other”—she reportedly shrugged—”at least for the time being.”

Raymond Hall/GC Images

“I know it sounds dreary and not sexy, but I think the most important part of it is companionship,” Parker added. “For me, it’s about asking myself: who do I want to sit with, in Ireland? ‘Who do I want to see those ruins with? Who is still the most challenging to me? Who do I like best?'”

About that very particular pitfall that almost all couples run up against after a long time, “It’s very normal to be interested in other people,” the actress said. “But it doesn’t mean you have to follow through.”

Parker and Broderick have weathered their own tough times and been the subject of split speculation—an inevitability in their line of work. When they bought their house in Brooklyn, the end was rumored to be coming, and there were rumors some years ago that Broderick cheated, about which SJP reflected to Harper’s Bazaar in 2013, “Yeah, I didn’t comment on it.”

Recalling a simpler time when she and her husband were just a couple of young actors trying to do good work, she added, “So when our marriage came up in conversation, it wouldn’t occur to us that we were obligated to respond to allegations or gossip. You have to be a bit circumspect, but you also have to take up a position, and you have to stick to it.”

Despite convincingly playing a character who has experienced the unraveling of a long marriage, Parker sounds blissfully un-jaded in her optimism about marriage’s potential for greatness.

“I think marriage has a lot of vitality,” she told People in February 2018. “If you’re fortunate, it’s like this dazzling organism.”

D Dipasupil/Getty Images

She and Broderick don’t go everywhere together—they happily do red carpets, but the Met Gala, for instance, is SJP’s thing—but they still share the same interests that they did back in the day (art, culture, theater, etc.) and are of course devoted to their three kids.  

But over all these years they seem to like each other as much as ever and having such busy—yet still pretty geographically cohesive—schedules has helped them grow individually and as a couple.

“I know this sounds nuts, but we have lives that allow us to be away and come back together,” Parker said in 2018 on Sophia Amoruso’s Girlboss Radio podcast. “His work life takes him here, and mine takes me there. In some ways, I think that that’s been enormously beneficial because we have so much to share in a way… anytime that any relationship is hard, it’s the point in which you’re deciding, is this worth the investment getting through whatever that thing is?”

James Devaney/GC Images

“Relationships are hard,” she acknowledged. “I always felt that I wanted to invest more. I love him, and I think he’s brilliant. I’m sure I annoy him. He annoys me sometimes. I’m enormously proud of the person he is. I think the longer you can last, the more invested you just are.”

But first and foremost…

“I love Matthew Broderick,” Parker declared in Harper’s Bazaar in 2013. “Call me crazy, but I love him. We can only be in the marriage we are. We’re very devoted to our family and our lives. I love our life. I love that he’s the father of my children, and it’s because of him that there’s this whole other world that I love.”

Keep reading to relive Parker and Broderick’s love story in photos:

Roy Rochlin/Getty Images

2022: Broadway Date Night

The two attend the opening night of Plaza Suite.

Bruce Glikas/WireImage

2022: Family Night

The pair appear with their kids James Wilkie Broderick, 20, and twins Tabitha Hodge Broderick and Marion Loretta Elwell Broderick, 13, at the premiere of the Broadway musical Some Like It Hot.

James Devaney/GC Images

2017: Ballet, But Make It Fashion

The two arrive at the New York City Ballet’s 2017 Fall Fashion Gala.

Mireya Acierto/FilmMagic

2015: A Night at the Theatre

The two attend the Irish Repertory Theatre’s YEATS: The Celebration at Town Hall in New York City.

Neil P. Mockford/Getty Images

2013: Pure Imagination

The two and their son James Wilkie Broderick attend the press night for Charlie and the Chocolate Factory at Theatre Royal in London.

Dave M. Benett/Getty Images

2013: London Calling

The two attend the annual Serpentine Gallery Summer Party, co-hosted by L’Wren Scott, at The Serpentine Gallery in London.

Jamie McCarthy/WireImage

2010: Here Come the Muggles

The couple and their son James Wilkie Broderick attend the New York City premiere of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows—Part 1.

Jason Merritt/Getty Images

2009: Oscars

The two arrive on the red carpet.

Kevin Mazur/WireImage

2003: SAG Awards

The two pose on the red carpet.

Ron Galella/Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images

1999: Emmys

The pair attend the awards ceremony.

Ron Galella, Ltd./WireImage

1998: Godzilla Premiere

The two are spotted at the New York City screening.

Ron Galella/WireImage

1995: Tony Awards

The couple celebrates the actor’s win for Best Actor in a Musical for How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying.

Ron Galella/Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images

1993: Golden Globes

The couple arrives at the awards ceremony.

This story was originally published on Thursday, May 17, 2018 at 10:22 a.m. PT.