Back From the Dead: Key Witness Shatters Miami Football Player Murder Trial With Explosive New Twist

Just as the long-delayed trial for the 2006 murder of former Miami Hurricanes defensive lineman Bryan Pata was about to begin, an unbelievable twist surfaced—one that could flip the entire case upside down.

Prosecutors had told the court for months that their key witness, Paul Conner—the man who lived in the apartment complex where Pata was shot—was dead. Yet, when ESPN reporters knocked on his Louisville, Kentucky, apartment door in August, Conner answered, very much alive.

That shock alone rattled the courtroom. But what happened next pushed the case into a surreal spiral.

When reporters pressed Conner on why prosecutors would think he was dead, Conner calmly explained that he was supposed to be. He claimed he had been placed into witness protection years ago after receiving threats tied to Pata’s murder. Conner said he’d been told by “officials” that in order to stay safe, he had to disappear—and that meant erasing his own identity, even faking his death on paper.

But here’s the kicker: Conner revealed he had been cooperating with someone else all along. He handed reporters a small notebook filled with names, phone numbers, and coded entries. The notes suggested that not only did he witness someone near the crime scene that night, but it wasn’t Rashaun Jones—the accused teammate—but another figure connected to Miami’s football program, someone no one had ever suspected.

Even crazier, buried in the notebook was an entry from 2019 referencing a “deal” with law enforcement to keep him silent in exchange for protection, an arrangement that seemingly unraveled when prosecutors declared him dead to the court.

Suddenly, the case is no longer just about whether Jones pulled the trigger. It’s about whether the system itself hid evidence, suppressed a witness, and manipulated the truth for nearly two decades.

Jones’s attorney called it “the biggest bombshell in Florida legal history,” insisting the discovery not only clears his client but exposes “a cover-up that goes far deeper than football.”

And with the trial date looming, the entire case now hinges on Conner’s testimony—the man once thought dead, now back to reveal secrets that could destroy careers, rewrite the narrative of a murder, and unravel one of college football’s darkest mysteries.

NFL Draft Diamonds was created to assist the underdogs playing the sport. We call them diamonds in the rough. My name is Damond Talbot, I have worked extremely hard to help hundreds of small school players over the past several years, and will continue my mission. We have several contributors on this site, and if they contribute their name and contact will be in the piece above. You can email me at [email protected]