Eagles Film Review: Jaire Alexander trade feels like a market opportunity

The Eagles are keeping me busy this week, acquiring Jaire Alexander from the Baltimore Ravens for essentially nothing. The Eagles are hoping a new environment can spark a resurgence, as he hasn’t played much this year and hasn’t played well when he has! Injuries have derailed Alexander’s career, sadly. For this review, I’ve separated it into two parts. Because he looks like a different player depending on whether you watch the 2024 or 2025 film!

2025 – Oh No

Alexander’s 2025 season in Baltimore was effectively non-existent. He appeared in just two games, saw limited action, and was quickly benched. The film was hard to watch. He just isn’t moving well enough, at all.

Against the Bills in Week 1, he struggled badly.

On an over route against Josh Palmer, Alexander resorted to clutching and grabbing, resulting in a 27-yard DPI penalty. He was slow to recognise routes and just didn’t look confident. He looked hesitant to me. His performance versus Keon Coleman in Week 5 showed how far his athleticism had slipped. A false step backward on a quick post left him entirely out of phase. He looks so clunky.

Against James Cook on a checkdown, he overran the play and failed to contain the edge. His tackling has looked very questionable, too. Which is obviously a problem.

The traits that once defined him were largely absent. He looked like a player overcompensating physically and mentally, trying to win reps with his hands because his legs couldn’t. He never looked comfortable in the scheme. In coverage, he was handsy and reactive. In run support, he arrived late or off-balance. The 2025 version of Jaire Alexander was not good enough.

2024 – Oh, Yes?

If you’re the Eagles, the optimism comes from his 2024 Packers film, not whatever has happened this year. Last season, when healthy, Alexander still looked like a good starting-caliber cornerback. He played almost exclusively outside (on both sides, which is important because the Eagles are asking Quinyon Mitchell to travel), and he looked good! He was very effective in press coverage. The Week 6 rep against Marvin Harrison Jr. was vintage Jaire Alexander. This is a perfect two-hand jam that staggered the receiver and disrupted the route entirely, and he also makes a nice breakup on the ball.

However, what truly stood out in 2024 was how well he played in a heavier zone coverage role. Green Bay ran one of the league’s highest zone rates, and Alexander’s vision, anticipation, and route recognition thrived in that structure. Which gives me some hope! Just look at how good this is…

Compare this route to the coverage you saw (on a nearly identical route) against Keon Coleman this year. It’s a different player!

He showed outstanding awareness to split high-low combinations and trigger downhill with timing. This is important in a zone-heavy scheme. He looked so comfortable compared to 2025. Was it just physical? Or mental too? Who knows.

In man coverage, though, the signs of decline remained. The Week 1 matchup with A.J. Brown was rough. He was beaten deep for over 100 yards, including a 67-yard touchdown after biting on a double move. When receivers gained early separation, he lacked the recovery burst to close the window. His tackling also regressed, which may reflect both physical problems and tentative movement post-injury.

Despite this, what cornerback doesn’t AJ Brown wreck in man coverage? He does this every week when teams play single-high man coverage! The 2024 version of Alexander is someone the Eagles could use. That’s the film the Eagles are banking on.

Overall

Fangio’s defense requires vision, discipline, and communication. Alexander fits more naturally into the zone-match framework the Eagles run, where he can play from depth, pass off routes, and react downhill instead of turning and running in isolation.

He’s unlikely to start immediately, but he gives Philadelphia an experienced rotational piece who is worth taking a look at. I think it’s a good move. He’s a once-elite corner whose body (or mind) has let him down, but whose football intelligence should remain intact. The 2025 film offers no reason for optimism, but the 2024 tape still shows a capable defender who can excel in zone coverage. His 2024 film is better than any Eagles cornerback on the roster, other than Quinyon Mitchell and Cooper DeJean. If the Eagles can somehow get him to play like that again (he is only 28, he’s not even in his 30’s!), then this trade will really help the Eagles this season.

I prefer this move to the Michael Carter II move because I think Alexander has shown he can be good more recently, and his upside is higher. This trade feels like a market opportunity. The Eagles saw a talented player at rock-bottom value who wasn’t even playing. If his knees hold up, and if a change of scenery helps him regain his confidence, this could look like a quiet steal. But expectations must be realistic. The 2025 film does suck.

The talent is still somewhere in there; whether it resurfaces is anyone’s guess. I like the gamble…

Thank you for reading! I’d love to hear your thoughts, so feel free to comment below and ask any questions. If you enjoyed this piece, you can find more of my work and podcast here. If you would like to support me further, please check out my Patreon here!