Idina Menzel Singing ‘New York, New York’ at Belmont Stakes Draws Mixed Fan Reactions

Each of the United States’ three Triple Crown horse races—in an only-in-America touch—has, or has had in the past, its own signature song.

The Kentucky Derby has “My Old Kentucky Home,” a Stephen Foster ballad popular during the Civil War. The Preakness Stakes formerly had the martial, pro-Confederate “Maryland, My Maryland”—finally jettisoned in 2020.

The Belmont Stakes, however, has the people’s champion—the beloved “New York, New York,” made famous by Frank Sinatra in 1980. Its fame, on par with “Happy Birthday,” makes it hard to butcher.

However, many fans weren’t feeling Broadway legend Idina Menzel’s rendition before the Belmont Stakes Saturday. You can judge for yourself here.

🎤 @idinamenzel sings “New York, New York” at Saratoga Springs as we get set for the 156th running of the @BelmontStakes! pic.twitter.com/s3dw4PqmB2

— FOX Sports (@FOXSports) June 8, 2024Some compared it to the most infamous sports vocal performance of this century—Fergie’s national anthem at the 2018 NBA All-Star Game.

It wasn’t quite Fergie’s NBA All-Star Game performance, but holy smokes Idina Menzel just wrecked New York, New York.#BelmontStakes

— Erik Pessolano (@erikpessolano) June 8, 2024Sinatra’s version was used as a point of reference (although to be fair, who could hope to compete with Frank Sinatra?)

They should play the Idina Menzel version of “New York New York,” when the Yankees lose. Not feelin’ it. #BelmontStakes

— Mike Gwizdala (@MikeGwizdala) June 8, 2024A few fans noted that Fox’s audio setup did Menzel no favors (this appeared especially true on the last verse).

Idina Menzel severely underestimated Fox’s ability to turn the mic to her audience…

— Alex H. (@hmlaa) June 8, 2024All told, theatre and horse racing made strange bedfellows.

Because when I think of horses running around in a circle, I think of Idina Menzel

— Becky Hammon, Hall of Famer (@kneary22) June 8, 2024Even fans of Menzel had to concede it wasn’t the finest hour for a vocal powerhouse.

I LOVE Idina Menzel but that rendition of New York New York was not great 👎 😞 #BelmontStakes

— Kristie Collins (@collinskristie) June 8, 2024