If Eric Adams Quits, New York Could See an Epic Grudge Match to Replace Him

The investigations and resignations swirling around New York City mayor Eric Adams have multiplied nearly nonstop for the past year. For that whole time, the disclaimer has been consistent whenever I asked his possible political challengers and their advisers about plans for challenging the mayor in a 2025 campaign: Only if Adams himself is indicted.

Well, that caveat crumbled this morning when Damian Williams, the United States attorney for the Southern District of New York, unsealed a five-count federal indictment against Adams. The charges include bribery, wire fraud, and conspiracy to receive campaign contributions by foreign nationals. The allegations stem largely from his victorious 2021 run for City Hall, as prosecutors claim he received campaign donations and travel benefits from entities connected to the government of Turkey in exchange for, as mayor, pressuring New York City Fire Department officials to approve an occupancy permit for the new Turkish consulate building that had not passed a fire-safety inspection. If those charges prove true, they’re both very on-brand for Adams—combining his long-running love for international excursions and glitz with his background in law enforcement—and depressingly petty and stupid.

The city’s history of political corruption is long and tawdry, but this is a first: No sitting mayor has ever been formally accused of criminal acts. Adams insists that any charges are “entirely false.” In a short video released Wednesday night after The New York Times broke the news of the impending indictment, the mayor said he would “fight these injustices with every ounce of my strength and my spirit.” He is a formidable fighter willing to work almost any angle in his defense. Adams has already invoked racism as a possible motivation for criticism of his administration; he has also alluded to the far-fetched idea of the federal investigations as being part of a Biden administration conspiracy to exact revenge for the mayor’s criticism of the president’s border policies.

Fending off the criminal charges will be tough for Adams, but the judicial process will be fairly slow. Faster-moving, more difficult, and well-underway is the political battle to hold onto his job. He’s already lost his police commissioner and schools chancellor to recent resignations; more top staff may now head for the exits. Rev. Al Sharpton, an Adams ally, has already delivered a worrisome signal, with the Times reporting he has “expressed concern” that the mayor’s mess could become a drag on other Democrats this fall, including Kamala Harris.

Calls for Adams’s resignation are escalating, but, so far at least, they’re mostly from Adams’s already declared reelection opponents or his long-standing adversaries, including Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and the Working Families Party. Key players to watch are Governor Kathy Hochul, who has had a friendly relationship with Adams but who has often miscalculated the city’s political dynamics; Senator Chuck Schumer, whose relationship with Adams has been cordial if mostly distant (though Schumer’s reaction to the indictment was fairly ominous: “No one is above the law, including the mayor of New York City”); and House Democratic majority leader Hakeem Jeffries. Jeffries is plenty busy at the moment, marshaling campaign troops to try to win New York congressional races in November, but he and Adams, both from Brooklyn, have very different personalities and politicians, and they have clashed in the past.

The city charter stipulates that if a mayor leaves office early, they are replaced by the city’s public advocate. This means that Democrat Jumaane Williams would move into the top job temporarily, with a special election required to take place within roughly 90 days. That’s when the fun would really start, and it’s why the already declared and most plausible contenders have quickly shifted from saying, “Only if Adams himself is indicted” to “If Adams quits.” Some would be better off if Adams departs soon; some would prefer he stay in office but decline to run for reelection next year. Here’s who to watch and the calculations they are making right now:

The 2013 favorite

For a long time, Christine Quinn looked to be on track to become the city’s first female mayor. But she got caught in the progressive backlash to three terms of plutocrat Mayor Michael Bloomberg and lost to Bill de Blasio. Lately, Quinn has been doing good work by running a nonprofit called Win that provides shelter and services to homeless women and children. But 11 years is a very long time to be off the radar with city voters.

The 2021 near miss

Kathryn Garcia lost to Adams by just 7,197 votes, or less than 1%, in the 2021 Democratic primary, the decisive contest in New York mayoral elections. That narrow margin and the fact that Garcia’s technocratic image would seemingly be a welcome antidote to all the Adams drama makes her a logical candidate. However, Garcia is said to be very happy in her current job as state director of operations in the Hochul administration and has no interest in running again now.

The existing 2025 field

Brad Lander has the strongest recent track record of winning actual city elections—three terms as a Brooklyn city councilman followed by, in 2021, a citywide contest to become comptroller. His campaign told The New York Times in July that it expected to have $3 million once anticipated matching funds were included; on the other hand, Lander may be too far left for some voters, and his attempts to be nuanced regarding Israel and Gaza may please no one. Zellnor Myrie is young (37) and energetic; he’s also little-known outside his Brooklyn state senate district. Jessica Ramos is young (39), charismatic, and somewhat better known outside her Queens state senate district. Scott Stringer, at 64, is the veteran: a former state assemblyman, borough president, and city comptroller. Stringer is making his second bid for mayor; the last one, in 2021, was derailed by a sexual misconduct allegation. (He has denied any wrongdoing.)

The possible interim mayor

Jumaane Williams is a left-wing activist turned politician. Williams, also from Brooklyn, spent two terms on the City Council before winning a 2019 special election to become a public advocate. Ninety days as interim mayor would give Williams a very large platform.

The dark horses

Jessica Tisch has held senior information technology jobs in the de Blasio administration; she’s currently Adams’s sanitation commissioner and is leading a major overhaul of how the city picks up garbage. She’s part of the Loews Corporation’s Tisch family, so she’d presumably have access to the necessary campaign money and be popular with the city’s business community. But Tisch is a virtual unknown with voters. Ritchie Torres, however, is very good at self-promotion. Currently a 36-year-old congressman representing a South Bronx district, Torres is an electric and sometimes polarizing presence. “He’s ambitious, Latino, and gay, and real estate and Jewish donors love him,” a Democratic operative tells me.

The lurking disgraced governor

Last November, shortly after FBI agents suddenly confronted Adams and seized his electronic devices, allies of Andrew Cuomo were already gaming out the advantages of a special election, telling me how the compressed campaign schedule would accentuate Cuomo’s strengths: nearly $8 million in campaign cash and much greater name recognition than his putative rivals. Those edges are still valid, and Cuomo has since made multiple speeches in Black churches around the city, keeping himself in front of a crucial voting group, especially in what would likely be a low-turnout contest.

Yet some recent reasons for Cuomo’s high name recognition aren’t helpful. In 2021, he quit as governor under a barrage of sexual harassment allegations (all of which he continues to deny). And just two weeks ago, Cuomo testified before a congressional committee investigating his handling of the COVID pandemic; his administration was criticized for concealing the actual number of deaths in nursing homes (Cuomo disputes this interpretation). If he runs for mayor, though, Cuomo would be the favorite. Probably. “I don’t know,” a former ally of the governor says. “The city has really changed. Are all those ethnic white voters who loved Mario and Andrew still around? And would Black voters go for him against a Black candidate?”

The disgraced governor’s mortal enemy

Which brings us to Tish James. She has previously talked of mayor being the job she dreamed of someday holding. James planned to run in 2021. But in 2018, scandal forced Eric Schneiderman out as state attorney general, so James ran—with the crucial backing of Cuomo—and won, which helped pave the way for Adams, her fellow Brooklynite, in the subsequent mayoral race. Relations between James and Cuomo have changed, to say the least. He blames her for using the sexual harassment allegations to railroad him out of Albany to stage her own gubernatorial bid (a motivation she dismisses, though James did run briefly in 2021 before ceding the race to Hochul). A showdown between James and Cuomo for City Hall would be irresistible theater. But it’s still hard to see James giving up her AG perch. If Adams quits and Cuomo gets in, however, James will come under considerable pressure to make a bid. “I think,” one of the city’s best-connected political players says, “she is the only one who can beat Andrew.”