Romania Appeals Gymnast Sabrina Maneca-Voinea’s Floor Exercise Score
Romanian Olympic Committee Appeals Gymnast’s Score After Jordan Chiles Inquiry
Sabrina Maneca-Voinea is taking it back to the judges table.
Days after Team USA gymnast Jordan Chiles submitted a successful inquiry about her score in the women’s floor exercise at the 2024 Paris Olympics that ultimately landed her the bronze medal, the Romanian Olympic Committee has appealed Sabrina’s final score in the Aug. 5 event, according to a social media post.
The 17-year-old was given a 0.1 deduction for stepping out of bounds during her routine, resulting in a final score of 13.700. However, replays seemingly showed her heel remaining inbounds.
President of the Romanian Olympic Committee Mihai Covaliu, however, urged the International Gymnastics Federationâthe official body behind the gymnastics competitionsâto reconsider Sabrina’s scoring, explaining than an initial challenge had been rejected.
“The way in which the score was assessed and the refusal to present the full reasons/proofs for the rejection of the appeal submitted within the time limit set by the rules seriously harms the image of international gymnastics,” he said in an Aug. 6 Facebook post, “but in particular affects the athlete, even jeopardizing their mental health.”
Sabrina and her fellow teammate Ana Barbosu were left to deal with the repercussions of the floor exercise scoring after they’d both finished with matching scores of 13.700, but because Ana had a higher execution score, she placed higher and by the end of the competition was in the bronze medal position.
Jamie Squire/Getty Images
However, Team USA’s Jordan’s coaches called for an inquiry, saying the initial evaluation didn’t credit Jordan with a tour jetĂ© fullâa skill she included in her trial and team finals, but did not get credit for. After her score inquiry was entered, Jordan’s score was boosted by 0.1, moving her ahead of both Sabrina and Ana to secure the third-place finish.
The dramatic score change sent shock waves around the globe, especially in Romania, with Prime Minister Marcel Ciolacu saying on Facebook Aug. 6 that he would boycott the Closing Ceremony.
Famed Romanian gymnast Nadia Comaneciâwho won nine medals during her Olympic careerâalso shared her thoughts on the matter, writing on X, formerly Twitter, Aug. 5, “I can’t believe we play with athletes mental health and emotions like this⊠let’s protect them #anabarbosu.”
Naomi Baker/Getty Images
As for Ana, the 18-year-old shared her gratitude on Instagram Stories following the event, writing, “Thank you to everyone who encouraged me before, during, and after the competition.”
Two days later she shared that she would be taking “a break from social media” after reiterating her thanks to supporters.
For more controversies that have occurred during the 2024 Paris Olympics so far, keep reading.
(E! and NBC are both part of the NBCUniversal family.)
Logan Riely/Getty Images
Canada Boots Women’s Soccer Coach
The 2024 Olympics had barely begun when Bev Priestman, head coach of the Canadian women’s soccer team, was removed from her post by Canada Soccer after her staff was accused of using drones to spy on the New Zealand team ahead of their group stage match.
“Additional information has come to our attention regarding previous drone use against opponents, predating the Paris 2024 Olympic Games,” Canada Soccer CEO and general secretary Kevin Blue said in a July 25 statement explaining the decision. “In light of these new revelations, Canada Soccer has made the decision to suspendâŠBev Priestman for the remainder of the Paris 2024 Olympic Games, and until the completion of our recently announced independent external review.”Â
Priestman apologized, saying in a statement, “I am absolutely heartbroken for the players, and I would like to apologize from the bottom of my heart for the impact this situation has had on all of them.”
The team, which won gold in Tokyo, is “a group of people who care very much about sportsmanship and integrity,” she continued. “As the leader of the team on the field, I want to take accountability, and I plan to fully co-operate with the [Canadian Soccer Association] investigation.”
JASPER JACOBS/BELGA MAG/AFP via Getty Images
South Korea Mistaken for North Korea During the Opening Ceremony
As the boat carrying athletes from South Korea came into view during the July 26 Opening Ceremony, they were incorrectly announced in both French and English as being from the Democratic People’s Republic of Koreaâwhich is North Korea.
South Korea, meanwhile, is the Republic of Korea.
In a July 27 statement, the International Olympic Committee noted, “We deeply apologize for the mistake that occurred when introducing the Korean team during the Opening Ceremony broadcast.”
IOC President Thomas Bach also called South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol to apologize, per the chief executive’s office, which relayed that Yoon told Bach the people of South Korea were “very shocked and embarrassed” by the mistake. An IOC spokesperson called the error an “operational mistake” that was “clearly deeply regrettable.”
Parade order is determined alphabetically according to the host nation’s languageâminus Greece, which always goes first as the home of the first Olympics, and the host nation goes last. South Korea was the 48th country in the Parade of Nations, while North Korea was 153rd.
Quinn Rooney/Getty Images
The Wrong Kind of Splash
British commentator Bob Ballard was pulled from Eurostar’s Olympics coverage for making a remark that was widely derided as sexist after Australian swimmers Mollie O’Callaghan, Shayna Jack, Emma McKeon and Meg Harris won gold in the 4×100-meter freestyle relay.
“Well, the women just finishing off,” Ballard said following the race. “You know what women are likeâŠhanging around, doing their makeup.”
His co-commentator Lizzie Simmonds replied, “Outrageous, Bob. Some of the men are doing that as well.”
Calling his comment “inappropriate,” Eurostar said in a July 29 statement Ballard had been removed with “immediate effect” from further coverage.
The veteran sportscaster promptly apologized.
“The comments I made during the Australian freestyle relay victory ceremony on Saturday have caused some offence,” he wrote on X. “It was never my intention to upset or belittle anyone and, if I did, I apologise. I am a massive advocate of womenâs sport.”
Jari Pestelacci/Eurasia Sport Images/Getty Images
A Rumor That Went Off the Deep End
After speculation that a too-shallow pool inside La Defense Arena was responsible for slower-than-expected times in swimming, the athletes torpedoed the idea that the water wasn’t deep enough to smash records.
“I think it’s totally a myth,” Team USA’s Regan Smith, who swam away from Paris with five medals, told NBCOlympics.com after she and Gretchen Walsh, Lilly King and Torri Huske set a new world record in the women’s 4×100-meter medley. “I think at first people were very aware of [the lack of new records]⊠So, I think that caused some chatter, like, ‘Oh, is it the pool that’s doing this?’ But I think as the meet went on, people got used to it, and then I think they got more comfortable with it, and then we started seeing some really fast swims.”
Added four-time medalist Walsh, “I think much of what the Olympics is, and what it represents, makes any pool that it’s at feel kind of slow. Because you have so much pressure on yourself that it is hard at your 100 percent best.”
Ana Vieira/Instagram
Swimmer Sent Home for “Indiscipline”
Brazilian swimmer Ana Carolina Vieira was sent home after, according to the Brazilian Olympic Committee, she committed two “acts of indiscipline”: She left the Olympic Village with boyfriend/teammate Gabriel Santos without permission, the BOC said, after acting “in a disrespectful and aggressive manner” in response to a “technical decision made by the Brazilian Swimming Team committee” regarding the 4x100m freestyle relay.
In a video titled “How a communication failure destroyed my Olympic dream,” Vieira lamented what happened but said, “everything is going to be solved at the right time.”
Luana Alonso/Instagram
Another Swimmer Kicked Out for “Inappropriate Atmosphere”
The Paraguayan Olympic Committee asked swimmer Luana Alonso to leave the Games, alleging in a statement that she had created an “inappropriate atmosphere at the Heart of Team Paraguay.”
“We thank her for proceeding as instructed,” the statement continued, “as it was of her own free will that she did not spend the night in the Athletes’ Village.”
The Southern Methodist University student had seemingly already returned to Texas when she wrote on Instagram Story (translated from Spanish) Aug. 5, “I just wanted to make it clear that I was never removed or expelled from anywhere, stop spreading false information. I donât want to give any statement but Iâm not going to let lies affect me either.”
Patrick Smith/Getty Images
MyKayla Skinner vs. Simone Biles
Simone Biles had already let it be known what she thought of Tokyo teammate MyKayla Skinner’s criticism of the U.S. gymnastics team selected to go to Parisâand Skinner had apologized for saying in a since-deleted video that “the talent and the depth just isn’t like what it used to be” and that “obviously a lot of girls don’t work as hard.”
But after the 2024 squad won team gold, Biles captioned a photo of the athletes, “Lack of talent, lazy, olympic champions”âan apparent jab at Skinner’s original comment.
On Aug. 6, Skinner reiterated in an Instagram video that she had “poorly” articulated her original point. But, she added, the cyberbullying she and her family had been subject toâfallout from her cyberfeud with Bilesâhad gotten out of hand.
She pleaded with the seven-time gold medalist “to please put a stop to this. Please ask your followers to stop.”
Sheng Jiapeng/China News Service/VCG via Getty Images
Beam In a Little Noise, Please
Neither Biles nor Suni Lee medaled in beam this year after both gymnasts fell off the apparatus during their final routines.
Afterward, Biles commented on the strangely quiet environment during their penultimate event in Paris.
“It was really weird and awkward,” the athlete, who earned bronze on beam in Tokyo, told the Associated Press. “We’ve asked several times if we can have some music, or some background noise. I’m not really sure what happened there, but yeah, not our favorite. None of us liked it.”
In response to the GOAT’s complaint, an International Gymnastics Federation said the atmosphere was “part of the sport presentation plan at Paris 2024.”
Lee noted that “the pressure was definitely on” and “a lot of people were definitely feeling it.”
She wondered if it was so quiet the nearby photographers could hear her breathing.
“It adds to the stress,” Lee said, “just because itâs like you, yes, you’re the only one up there. So I was feeling the pressure.â
Xavier Laine/Getty Images
Gymnastics Scoring Shocker
Jordan Chiles seemingly finished out of the running for a medal when she completed her floor exercise final routine and received a score of 13.666, Romania’s Ana Barbosu ahead of her in third place with a score of 13.700.
But after Team USA filed a score inquiry on Chiles’ behalf and her performance was further reviewed by the judges, her start value was increased by one-tenth of a point. As a result, her score was subsequently bumped up to 13.766. Meaning, she got the bronze and Barbosuâwho was already waving her country’s flag in celebrationâleft the arena in tears.
Afterward, Barbosu posted a video of herself competing and wrote, “Thank you to everyone who encouraged me before, during, and after the competition.”
Image Photo Agency/Getty Images
5,000 Meters Scoring Shocker
Medal adjustments haven’t been confined to the gymnastics arena.
Kenyan runner Faith Kipyegon was initially disqualified for seeming to jostle Gudaf Tsegay of Ethiopia during the women’s 5,000 meters at the Stade de France on Aug. 5, negating her second-place finish.
“I have never seen anything like that, in an Olympic final that went on for so long,” commentator Kara Goucher, a two-time Olympian, said on the broadcast, noting that the two women also appeared to exchange heated words. “You see a little bit of elbow, you see a little bit of frustration, but that was many strides and scolding.”
It wasn’t until the wee hours of Aug. 6 that Kipyegon found out her silver medal had been reinstated. The Olympic Jury of Appeal ruled that, while there had been “significant contact” between her and Tsegay, “the incident did not warrant a disqualification.”
With that, Italy’s Nadia Battoclettiâthe fourth-place finisher bumped into bronze position by the disqualificationâwas re-relegated to fourth.
Quinn Rooney/Getty Images
Swimming Disqualifications That Stood
Two athletes’ hopes of a medal were dashed when they unwittingly broke rules mid-swim, meaning they didn’t even know they were out until they finished their races.
Great Britain’s Luke Greenbank finished first in his 200-meter backstroke heat but was disqualified for staying underwater for further than the maximum 15 meters after first diving in.
“Win or lose Iâve always been my own harshest critic but sometimes youâve just got to take it as it comes,” he wrote on Instagram Aug. 1. “I can take pride in the fact that I know I was in great shape coming into these games after a tough few years, but this will motivate me to come back stronger.”
A technical error also knocked Alex Walsh off the 200-meter individual medley podium after she finished in the bronze position. As she approached the wall during the last leg of her backstroke, she made an illegal turn by starting to flip out of position before she tapped the wall and launched into her breaststroke.
“Still proud,” Walsh wrote on Instagram Aug. 6, thanking her supporters a few days after the race. “Despite the DQ, this Olympics has been an experience that has left me feeling happy and fulfilled, and I will cherish that forever. After all, everything happens for a reason and there is so much more to be excited about for me in this sport.”
Ezra Shaw/Getty Images
Something in the Water?
Despite $1.53 billion having been budgeted to clean up the perennially polluted Seine, reports swirled for months leading up to the Paris Games about whether it would be safe enough to hold the swimming leg of the triathlons and the 10,000-meter marathons in the river.
Paris Mayor Anne Hidalgo went for a swim July 17 and declared France’s most famous body of water good to goâbut it’s been kind of a s–t show since the Olympics began.
On Monday, July 29, swims for the triathletes to familiarize themselves with the Seine were canceled, officials citing poor water quality levels caused by run-off from the weekend’s heavy rains (which noticeably started during the July 26 Opening Ceremony).
The men’s triathlon was then postponed a day and rescheduled to follow the women’s event on July 31 after organizers deemed bacteria levels too high for a safe swim.
Both triathlons were held July 31, day-of tests finding that E. coli and intestinal enterococci levels were low enough to qualify the water as “excellent quality,” per the European Union’s Bathing Water Directive.
But speculation that the water wasn’t safe resumed after two athletes who competed in the triathlon dropped out of the mixed-relay competition, citing respective illnesses (neither of which have been definitively linked to swimming in the Seine).
The women’s and men’s 10,000 meters are still scheduled for Aug. 8 and 9, but practices were canceled Aug. 6 after tests showed bacteria levels were once again too high.
Watch the 2024 Paris Olympics daily on NBC and Peacock until the summer games end with the Closing Ceremony on Sunday, Aug. 11, at 7 p.m. ET/PT.
